Little Girl Raised as Witch – Magical or Weird?

by Laura Driver

The father of an eight year old girl has shared his story on Reddit revealing that he and his wife have been raising their daughter to believe she was a witch for nearly three years now. He explained that ever since they started reading the Harry Potter books to her when she was five, they have told her the Wizarding World is real and that she is in fact a witch.

Now the parents are running out of ways to keep the lie going, which bought the father to Reddit, to ask for help. He said they were looking for "more sophisticated and creative ideas from the Harry Potter community to keep this thing going".


In the post, the father explained that her questions about the Wizarding World and her status as a witch have got "deeper", and that he and his wife have "kept building the illusion with more details about our family genealogy and its connection to book characters", as well as telling her "stories" about times they have used magic.

He went on to explain that through this belief, their little girl has "processed many difficult subjects" like racism, climate change and even coronavirus.

Aware that their parenting style may cause some backlash, the father wrote: "Before other parents judge or lecture, we know its gas-lighting and that eventually she'll have be disappointed and have trust issues with us when she learns the truth.


"We justify it that we are adding magic to her childhood and giving her motivation to reach her full (magical) potential (since she needs to study hard to be accepted to Hogwarts). We've asked serious questions of her teachers and they think it's more awesome and creative than damaging." He added: "At the very worst case, my take is that its analogous to children being raised to believe that traditional religious stories are true and that when the truth hits it will teach her to ask critical questions and not accept everything she hears or reads at face value."

And, as he expected, people are divided by their way of raising their child.

One person commented on Twitter about the Reddit post: "This kid is going to need millions of dollar’s worth of therapy and I hope the parents are prepared to pay for that."


However, another argued that this isn't much different than raising your children to believe in the Tooth Fairy. He posted: "On the one hand this is very weird and I don’t think they really thought this through. On the other hand I’m trying to say how this differs from e.g. convincing your kids there’s a tooth fairy, beyond there being a pre-existing tooth fairy myth that most other children believe."

One person online even said that her mum did the same thing to her when she was a child.

She explained: "Ok so my mother did this to me HARD (like, she wrote me an acceptance letter on parchment, got me a cauldron, etc), and it was really f**ked up when she broke the news to me."

If you enjoyed reading this article why not share it with others!

Written by

Laura Driver

Blogger & Social Media Manager
Laura lives in Yorkshire, UK with her two teenage children. When they were little (and definitely not taller than her) she used to blog avidly about the trials and tribulations of motherhood. Laura is no stranger to all the joys small children can bring; sleepless nights, a random public meltdown or a spectacular poonami. She fondly remembers the time her youngest child rolled across a supermarket carpark in a trolley while she was putting her eldest child in the car and the time her, then, three year old took up swearing at a church event. Laura has worked for Your Baby Club, as a Social Media Manager, since 2014.

Articles on are a mixture of informative pieces, anecdotal accounts and professional advice from our panel of Bloggers, Writers and Experts. The views and opinions expressed in these articles are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official view of Your Baby Club UK

Related articles